A water softener does its work out of sight, so it is fair to wonder whether it is doing anything at all. You can tell without tools: soft water shows up in your soap, your dishes and your salt tank. This guide gives five checks, explains how long regeneration takes and how often it should run, and lists what to look at when the softener stops.
Five signs your water softener is working
- Soap lathers easily. Soap, shampoo and dish soap foam up quickly, and you need less of them.
- No new spots or scale. Glasses dry clear, and no new white crust forms on faucets and showerheads.
- The salt level goes down. Slowly, over weeks. A Zenith softener usually needs a salt refill every 2 to 3 months.
- It regenerates. Every few days you may hear water running to the drain for a while, usually at night.
- The water tests soft. A hardness test at a softened tap reads at or near zero.
A test you can do today
Hardness test strips cost a few dollars. Test the cold water at a kitchen or bathroom tap, then compare the color with the chart on the pack. Softened water should read at or near zero grains per gallon. For comparison, untreated Indianapolis water is about 19 grains per gallon (see our Indianapolis water hardness guide).
No strips? Try the soap test. Fill a clear bottle one third full with tap water, add a few drops of plain liquid soap and shake. Plenty of suds and clear water underneath mean the water is soft.
How long does water softener regeneration take?
Most softeners take between about 70 minutes and 2 hours to regenerate, depending on the model and its settings. During that time the softener washes its resin with salt water to clear out the hardness it has collected, rinses the resin, and refills the salt tank with water for next time.
Softeners are normally set to regenerate in the middle of the night, when nobody is using water. A single tank softener does not soften while it regenerates, so water drawn during that time is hard. A dual tank water softener keeps one tank in service while the other regenerates, so soft water never stops.
How often should a water softener regenerate?
It depends on how hard your water is, how many people live in the home and the size of the softener. Most modern softeners are metered: they count the gallons you use and regenerate only when the resin is nearly used up. Older timer models regenerate on set days whether they need to or not.
For a family of four, a Zenith softener regenerates about every 5 to 6 days and uses 35 to 65 gallons of water each time. A softener that regenerates every day, or one that never seems to regenerate, needs a look.
Signs your water softener has stopped working
- Spots, scale and soap scum are coming back
- Soap no longer lathers the way it did
- The salt level has not moved in weeks
- The salt tank is full of water
- Water runs to the drain without stopping
- The softener is using far more salt than usual
Our water softener repair page answers the common ones: water in the salt tank, a softener that is not using salt, resin beads in the water and water that has turned hard again.
What to check before you call
- Salt level. The salt tank should be at least a quarter full.
- Salt bridge. A hard crust can form above the water line and stop salt from dissolving. Push gently on the salt with a broom handle to see if it is hollow underneath.
- Bypass valve. If the valve was moved during other plumbing work, water may be skipping the softener.
- Power and clock. After a power cut, check that the control valve is on and showing the right time.
If all four are fine, start a regeneration by hand from the control valve, following your owner’s manual, and test the water again the next day.
When to book a visit
If the water is still hard after a regeneration, something inside the softener needs attention. For a Zenith system, request service; most visits are booked within 3 business days. A softener that is past ten years old may be at the point where replacing it makes more sense. See repair or replace.
Zenith repairs and services Zenith systems only. If your softener is another brand, we can test your water for free and give you trade-in credit toward a new system. Book your free water test.
Water softener questions
How can I tell if my water softener is regenerating?
You will hear water running to the drain, and the control valve usually shows the cycle on its display. Most softeners are set to do this in the middle of the night.
How long does a water softener take to regenerate?
Between about 70 minutes and 2 hours for most softeners, depending on the model and its settings.
How often should a water softener regenerate?
It depends on your water hardness, your household and the size of the softener. For a family of four, a Zenith softener regenerates about every 5 to 6 days.
Can I use water while my softener is regenerating?
Yes, but with a single tank softener that water is not softened. That is why regeneration is set for the night. A dual tank softener gives soft water the whole time.
How long does a water softener last?
Most last 10 to 15 years. Our article on how long water softeners last explains what shortens or extends that life.

